THE PROJECT
About | Summary | Hall |
L'Affaire Eagleson
| Committee | Rules | Initial Thoughts
| New-Found Respect For the Chore?
  ELECTIONS
 
DIFFERENCES OF OPINIONS
World Wide Hall of Fame vs.
Toronto Hall of Fame
FEEDBACK
Submit Comments
PRINT VERSION
Download (PDF)
 

ABOUT THE PROJECT

Gordie Howe, upon the passing of Jean-Claude Tremblay, expressed surprise when Mr. Hockey found out the former Canadien and Nordique defenseman was not in the Hall of Fame. "He's got five Cups. I've only got four," said Mr. Hockey.

FROM THE COMMITTEE TO RECOGNIZE TRUE EXCELLENCE
MOREY HOLZMAN, CHAIR
ARTHUR CHIDLOVSKI
LLOYD DAVIS
JAMES DUPLACEY
ERNIE FITZSIMMONS
IAIN FYFFE
PATRICK HOUDA
GORD JENNINGS
JASON KASIOREK
KEITH LENN
ROB MATIC
JOSEPH NIEFORTH
JOE PELLETIER
KARL-ERIC REIF
LARRY ROBERTSON
HOWARD ROSENTHAL
LARRY SEKULER
BILL SWIFT
SEBASTIEN TREMBLAY
BILL UNDERWOOD
MIKE WYMAN

NOTE: Special thanks to former WWHOF Commitee members:
DAVID STEWART-CANDY
DAVE HOLLAND

In a broader picture, Mr. Hockey has defined the very problem of the Hall of Fame: there are so many people elected that few know (or have even heard of) all of the honoured. The level of excellence has been lowered so that if one wins five Stanley Cups, the expectation is they should be enshrined.

In his 2003 autobiography, Thunder and Ice, Phil Esposito comments that his Hall of Fame induction day meant little.

Said the man who trailed just Gordie Howe on the NHL's all-time goal scoring list when he retired in 1980, "It wasn't that big a deal to me because I feel there are some players in the Hall who shouldn't be there, and as a result it sort of cheapens it for everyone."

The Hockey Hall of Fame selection committee's selection methods and criterion have come under ridicule and discussion since the first election in 1945. Even today, the selection method works something like this: a player is nominated, and the 18 committee members say yea or nay. If 75% of the voting members approve, we will soon be honoring a new member of the Hockey Hall of Fame. And no one on the committee goes home until someone gets chosen.

The current committee is made up of retired players, current Hall of Famers, an executive or two, and a journalist or two. The main problem with the Toronto-centric nature of the Hall is a disproportionate amount of Maple Leafs in its environs, and a nearly complete lack of Americans and Europeans. Other organizations, such as the United States Hall of Fame and the IIHF Hall of Fame, have formed to fill the gap, but their niche view has left a vacancy in terms of a hockey hall of fame truly representative of the best hockey players of all-time, the best hockey leaders of all-time, all enshrined yet limited in numbers so that only the best of the best are recognized.

But more importantly, future hockey fans can learn the game's great legacy.

This is what we hoped to accomplish. No one and no one subject was sacred. We didn't prejudge the original WHA just because Harold Ballard lost some players. We were unified in our stated goal: to protect the legacy of those who were its greatest players, and those who were great for the game.

We are a committee of 21 researchers – some Society of International Hockey Research members and others not – from across the globe, spanning career fields, all with one goal: to make our Hall of Fame the best of the best. Since it is incredibly inhumane to just kick members out because they are no longer "good enough," a new Hall, with new, consistent voting requirements, provides one solution.

So who's in, who's out, and who's making these decisions?

Well, don't worry. We didn't kick out Gordie Howe, or Bobby Hull or Bobby Orr, and we managed to protect Eddie Shore and Howie Morenz. And Bill Cook. Larry Murphy, however, was booted out of Toronto a second time.

Like Toronto, we are prejudiced against defenseman with a team-first mentality, even though hockey, if nothing else, is the ultimate in team sports. But when you are looking at a ballot, like we did in 1985, with Howe, Bobby Hull, Stan Mikita, John Bucyk, Andy Bathgate, Bernie Parent and Ken Dryden, Yvan Cournoyer and Gerry Cheevers, and then add in Alexander Ragulin, Nikolai Sologubov, Lars-Erik Sjoberg and Tord Lundstrom for international flavor, and you can only pick five, well, several great defensemen were left behind the play.

Our processes and some thoughts follow on the remaining sections of this on-line presentation.